Why a 50% Carbohydrate Diet Gives Dogs Cancer
The piece below is taken from my forthcoming book. Please share with any vet recommending a high carbohydrate diet for a dog, and ask them for their opinion.
“Studies using dogs provide an ideal solution to filling the gap in animal models of natural disease and translational medicine” (Rowell et al. 2011). Cancers such as bone cancer, lymphoma and bladder cancer are molecularly identical to cancers in people. When viewed under a microscope, it is impossible to distinguish between a tumour from a human and a dog. Moreover their cancer responds to treatments in similar ways. Thus dogs are excellent models for the development of cancer in humans (Moe 2001, Dobson 2012). It stands to reason that the opposite must too apply. For this reason, this section will lean on nutritive lessons learned in human cancer development.
Only 5–10% of all cancer cases in humans can be attributed to genetic defects. The remaining 90–95% have their roots in the environment and lifestyle (Anand et al. 2008). Diet plays a very significant role in the development of cancer in humans, with poor quality fats, too much red meat (particularly processed red meat), too much salt and too much carbohydrates (sugar) listed among the most common protagonists (Stewart and Wild 2014).
Tumours are total carb / sugar junkies. In fairness, all cells need sugar to operate but cancer cells use glucose at 10-20 times the rate of normal cells (Bäck 2011, Connealy 2017). Their high sugar-uptake is actually the main way we look for them, using a method called a PET-CT (Positron Emission Tomography and Computed Tomography) scan. PET scans use radioactively labeled glucose to detect sugar-hungry tumour cells. When patients drink the sugar water, the mix gets preferentially taken up by the cancer cells and they light up. This helps physicians see where it is, to evaluate the extent of the disease, to deduce which treatments to use and to check if those treatments are working. In fact, all the way back in 1931 Otto Warburg won the Nobel Prize for his discovery that cancer cells have a different energy metabolism to healthy cells, notably a greater rate of glycolysis (the process of converting glucose to energy) compared with normal cells.
In this way, a high sugar diet and cancer are the best of friends, but the relationship goes much deeper than that. Macrophage-mediated programmed cell removal (PrCR), or phagocytosis for short, plays an essential role in tumour surveillance and elimination. These are the seek, engulf and destroy cells of the immune system. We’ve known since 1971 that just 100g of sugar via sucrose, honey or orange juice significantly reduces phagocytosis in humans and the effect can last up to five hours (Sanchez et al. 1973, Ringsdorf et al. 1976). If you’re a cancer cell thinking of getting up to mischief, this is most welcome.
It gets worse. As more and more sugar is consumed, cell-resistance to insulin builds, meaning more and more insulin is released into the blood. Insulin is a powerful stimulant of cell growth as it drives fuel into the cell. Cancer cells have 10-20 times the insulin receptors of normal cells (Bäck 2011, Connealy 2017) which enables them to gorge on glucose. In this way, excess sugar leading to obesity and high blood insulin is an important factor in cancer (Calle et al. 2003).
These insulin receptors are everywhere in your body. Hence too much sugar, coupled with excess insulin, is now firmly linked to the development of cancer of the breast, ovaries, pancreas, biliary tract, lung, gallbladder, stomach and colorectal cancer of humans (Takahashi 1982, Moerman et al. 1993, De Stefani 1998, Cornee et al. 1999, Dana-Farber 2002, Michaud 2002, Larsson et al. 2005, Schernhammer et al. 2005, Lamkin et al. 2009).
Tavani et al. (2006) studied 2,569 women with breast cancer and 2,588 females without. They found a direct association between breast cancer risk sugar consumption, a result of an increase in insulin and insulin growth factors. Unsurprisingly, the advice for humans with mammary tumours is to reduce the carbohydrate / sugar content of your diet.
It happens that mammary tumours are the most frequently diagnosed neoplasm in intact female dogs (Moe 2001). What’s more, dogs are known to suffer mammary cancer at least 2 to 3 times the rate of humans (Schneider 1970, ACVS 2017). The incidence of breast cancer in human females is currently around 12% worldwide (McGuire et al. 2015). On their website in 2017, the American College of Veterinary Surgeons states the that the risk of a female dog developing a mammary tumour is “0.5% if bitches are spayed before their first heat (approximately 6 months of age), 8% after their first heat, and 26% after their second heat”. That’s 1 in 4 intact female dogs (the ACVS go on to state that while 50% of mammary tumours are benign and 50% are malignant though thankfully few of the malignant mammary tumours are fatal).
The rather complicated graph below highlights that dogs maintained on a relatively low-starch (23%), dry diet exhibited significant rises in blood insulin (Hewson-Hughes et al. 2011), with a near doubling in plasma insulin release (190 versus 360pmol/l plasma insulin) in dogs fed a low (10%) and high (32%) starch diet. Most cereal-based dry foods contain at least 50% starch (from a variety of sources including cereals such as wheat and corn but now pea, potato, rice etc).
As we know mammary gland tumours share common features between dogs and humans, with authors noting dogs make excellent models for the development, prognosis and treatment of breast cancer in humans (Moe 2001, Dobson 2012), does it not follow that a high carbohydrate diet and permanently high blood insulin will plays a significant role in this the most common cancer of dogs?!
I’ll save you the suspense. Studies show reducing carbohydrates in the diet prevents tumour growth in dogs (Ogilvie 1998). The author notes that dogs with cancer are proven to do significantly better on diets containing less carbohydrates.”
My dog has Cancer, What do I do?
If your dog has cancer, and you’ve been to the vet, you must consider the following:
- Move your dog to a carb / sugar-free diet. That is, any fresh meat and bone diet. Remove all sources of sugar including rice, all fruit, starch-rich veg such as peas, carrots and potatoes. Feed them like a carnivore to starve tumour growth.
- Remove any pet store treats that contain cereal / dairy / sugar anything that as has been chemically preserved. Make your own meat-based treats.
- Remove all chemical flea and worm treatments and all boosters. All have been linked to cancer in dogs. Stop with all the products.
- Add in some good quality fats (krill oil or starflower).
- Make golden turmeric paste for dogs. As the link will show, there 14 independent studies that show turmeric fights cancer.
- Studies show astaxanthin is very effective in the fight against cancer. It can be very expensive. I go to Amazon and look at the ones with the best reviews and price. [geot continent=”Europe” exclude_country=”United States”]This one by Livoa Vital has more than 450 reviews, with 70% of them being 5 star.[/geot][geot country=”United States” exclude_continent=”Europe”]This one by BioAstin has more than 2.6k reviews, with 77% of them being 5 star.[/geot]
- Pick up some good quality seaweed. It has some unbelievable anti-cancer properties. Here are 13 independent studies that show seaweeds fight cancer growth. We picked four of the main seaweeds used in these studies and put them in a highly popular product we call AC4. You have to be very careful making any sort of claims about cancer, we can only hope it will help.
All these things can be done IN CONJUNCTION with conventional veterinary treatment. If your vet is recommending a dry, carb-based dog food for your dog with cancer they are categorically wrong and I urge you to seek the advice of a vet that has studied at least nutrtion. It will keep growing if you keep feeding it.
[All references above available on request].