Keeping dogs out of vets since 2011

Why Do Vets Recommend “That” Dry Food?!

Why Do Vets Recommend “That” Dry Food?!

Are Irish vets not yet wondering why the only dry food they choose to stock (Royal Canin) is rated a miserable 2.5 stars out of 5 by Dog Food Advisor? With Science Diet not performing that much better (3 stars out of 5).

I mean, you’d think they’d get behind a highly rated (if not, dare we dream, the best) one, wouldn’t you?!

Among a number of issues with Royal Canin Dog Food Advisor (DFA) lists:

  • it has grain as it’s number one ingredient (and often it’s second)
  • uses by product meals (powder from rendering plants using “slaughterhouse waste”)
  • they include wheat gluten, corn gluten and beet pulp (stuff left over from processing these ingredients for the human food industry) in it’s first 10 ingredients. These indigestible and, in the case of wheat gluten notably, often antigenic proteins boost the protein percentages on the side of the packet irrespective of the fact that dog can neither digest nor utilise it. The DFA more politely states these ingredients are “expected to have a lower biological value than meat.

If I could add to this list the question of source. Royal Canin contains ingredients that are sourced, if not the product manufactured in, China. Try find out some more as I got nowhere.

Needless to say this is not to question what are acceptable practices of the dry food industry, no rules being broken there, but it’s safe to say that if there are literally hundreds if not thousands of companies making better dry food today, why oh why do our vets keep promoting it?

First Dentists to Promote Toothpaste, now Vets to Promote Dog Food…

A great article by Parker-Pope in the Wall Street Journal way back in 1997 explains. The author highlights the move of pet food manufacturers into the 27 US veterinary universities in the 90’s (Parker-Pope 1997) using extremely generous cash “donations”.

It began with Colgate Palmolive (CP, makers of Hills Science Diet and Prescription Diets). At the time they were using dentists to promote it’s toothpaste in the 80’s (extremely successful) and then thought maybe we could use vets in the same way to promote dry food!

Sadly the use of financial incentive continues on into veterinary practice. John Steel, a once senior vice president of global marketing and sales for CP said on record

…the bulk of our expenditure goes to the veterinary community…

What this figure is remains unknown but safe to say with the walls of every local vet now adorned with an add for one of their 160 vet-prescribed Hills Science diets, it has been money well spent.

You Could Say It’s Not Their Fault…

This all goes some way to explaining why modern vets recommend dry foods that perform extremely poorly when assessed by dry food measuring websites. A number of authors highlight how due to the marketing efforts of pet food manufacturers our vets now find themselves totally out of their depth (Londsdale 2001, Berschneider 2002, Stogdale and Diehl 2003, Martin 2007).

So, in a way, you could say it’s not their fault.

But at the same time you would be forgiven for asking how a trained scientist is not asking the question they should be. Hows about picking up any canine nutrition book not written by a dry food company? Ideally, how about putting fresh feeding to the test?!

Winnipeg veterinarians Stogdale and Diehl (2003) highlight:

…becoming competent in nutrition requires a great deal of reading and research — most of which is boring, contradictory, and confusing. We understand why the majority of veterinarians do not elect to spend their continuing education time on studying this field; it’s so much easier and more efficient to recommend a bag of commercial pet food…

In a piece entitled “Who is responsible for the efficacy and safety of pet foods?” MacMillan (2008) goes further. In response to comments by one Dr. Buffington in 2008 who stated there were no studies to suggest there was anything wrong with pet food Dr. MacMillan (2008) promptly sourced 70 veterinary researched papers that directly blamed pet food for causing cancer, kidney failure, cystitis, dilated cardiomyopathy, struvite crystals, calcium oxalate stones among many other illnesses in pets.

MacMillan concludes strongly:

Veterinarians who make money out of the sale of pet foods and from the illnesses they create are betraying pets and pet owners by failing to tell them that feeding such poor quality nutrition will eventually cause illness in the pet.

References

Parker-Pope, T. (1997). For You, My Pet: Why the Veterinarian Really Recommends That Designer Chow – Colgate Gives Doctors Treats For Plugging Its Brands, And Sees Sales Surge – Offering a Fat-Cat Bounty. Wall Street Journal (Eastern Edition), November 3rd, p. A1

Share This Article

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email

Categories

Need Advice?

1-to-1 Online Consultations

Should you need a little hand holding, I’m here to help. Consultations are typically 1 hour in length: 15 minutes to read your presubmitted questionnaire and prepare for your pet, 30-40 minutes with you directly via Zoom / Skype and 10-15 minutes to write your summary email, including all necessary tips and their diet plan. It also includes a follow up email should you need it.

MY BEST SELLER

5/5
"Finally! A well-written, well-referenced thorough examination of the raw dog food debate. A fantastic gift for your favourite veterinarian."
Dr. Karen Becker

Subscribe

For the most up-to-date advice, support, tips and ticks from Dr. Brady and his team, please subscribe below .

Related Articles

Meal volume may cause bloat in dogs
Raw dog food

The Best Diet for Dogs with Kidney Disease – Go Fresh, Go Natural!

If you have read the first three parts of our articles on kidney failure in dogs, you will understand the kidney’s role in the body and what happens when they stop functioning. Part two details the top foods that cause kidney failure in dogs. Article three explains how low-protein dog food would almost certainly not

Read More »
Fresh, good-quality protein for dogs with kidney disease
Raw dog food

Kidney failure in dogs – Could dry food be fuelling this disease?

In veterinary circles, the jury is still out on why so many pets today are suffering from kidney disease. Cats are twice as likely to get kidney disease than dogs (Veterinary Medical Database, University of Purdue) which largely rules out a genetic cause.  If genetics were solely to blame, then dogs should suffer more than

Read More »
Itchy dog DF dog
Raw dog food

Allergies in Dogs: Symptoms, Causes, Treatment & Remedies

Allergies in dogs is a big subject, and what’s more, the list of dog allergy symptoms can make you dizzy. Unfortunately, this can make the whole matter very confusing…in someone else’s hands! We at Dogs First are the dog allergy specialists, and below, in the most popular and most visited article on the site, we

Read More »
Turmeric for dogs
Dog Health

Turmeric For Dogs – Natures Most Powerful Anti-Inflammatory

The amount of info about turmeric for dogs is incredible. Unlike most herbal remedies, turmeric has a vast amount of high-quality scientific and clinical studies supporting it and testifying to its incredible anti-inflammatory properties.  The primary pharmacological bit in turmeric is called curcumin (that’s the deep orange colour). Clinical research has shown that curcumin is

Read More »